Tractor Supply Rides on Rural Resilience Amid Looming Margin Pressure

Tractor Supply Company TSCO thrives at the intersection of rural lifestyle and essential retail, serving a customer base often overlooked by big-box peers. Its model is anchored in need-based categories, such as pet, livestock and land care, providing resilience even in volatile economic conditions.

Tractor Supply delivered another record second-quarter fiscal 2025, underscoring the resilience of its rural-focused model. Sales growth was fueled by core consumable, usable and edible categories, along with strong seasonal recovery after a slow spring. Customer engagement remains a key strength, with loyalty membership reaching new highs and making meaningful contributions to traffic and ticket growth. Expansion initiatives like Garden Centers, pet services and store openings further reinforce the company’s position as the go-to retailer for rural lifestyle needs.

At the same time, management is actively investing in long-term growth levers, particularly its Final Mile delivery initiative, which is proving to be a differentiator in rural logistics. By handling bulky, high-weight items with trusted service, Tractor Supply gains strength against larger competitors entering the rural market. PetRx, digital channels and retail media are additional incremental growth drivers that expand customer engagement and revenue streams. Together, these initiatives provide confidence in the company’s ability to capture share across key lifestyle categories.

However, margin pressures loom on the horizon. Inflationary effects, tariff-driven cost increases and ongoing SG&A investments are expected to weigh on the company in the second half of 2025. While disciplined cost control and supply chain efficiencies provide some buffer, the company acknowledges that gross margin expansion will slow, with the operating margin trending at the lower end of its estimated range.

For investors, Tractor Supply’s strong fundamentals, loyal customer base and strategic growth pipeline offer long-term appeal, though the near-term performance will depend on its ability to balance resilience in rural demand with cost headwinds.

TSCO’s Retail Peers: Their Business Model vs. Margin Pressures

Build-A-Bear Workshop’s BBW experiential retail model blends in-store personalization, e-commerce and partner-operated locations, creating strong engagement across demographics. Its diversified channels, including licensing and entertainment, enhance brand reach while driving consistent growth. 

The company reported record second-quarter fiscal 2025 results, supported by an improved gross margin through reduced promotions and selective price increases. However, rising SG&A expenses from labor, corporate costs and inflation highlight margin pressures. Sustaining profitability will depend on balancing cost discipline with continued investment in global expansion and digital initiatives.

Sally Beauty Holdings, Inc. SBH operates a differentiated model as the leader in professional hair color, serving both retail and wholesale customers through Sally Beauty and Beauty Systems Group. Its omnichannel approach, including strong digital growth, continues to reinforce its market position.

The “Fuel for Growth” program has delivered four straight quarters of margin expansion and double-digit EPS growth in third-quarter fiscal 2025. However, pressures from labor, IT investments and macro-driven softness in consumer spending remain key challenges, even as SBH raises the full-year margin guidance.

DICK'S Sporting Goods, Inc. DKS operates a differentiated omni-channel model, combining athlete-centric stores, digital platforms and exclusive vertical brands to build loyalty and drive share gains. Its House of Sport and Field House formats deepen engagement while e-commerce continues to outpace overall growth.

However, margin expansion faces headwinds from SG&A deleverage as the company invests heavily in stores, digital and marketing. While the gross margin benefits from merchandise strength, sustained profitability will hinge on balancing growth investments with cost discipline.

Want the latest recommendations from Zacks Investment Research? Today, you can download 7 Best Stocks for the Next 30 Days. Click to get this free report

This article originally published on Zacks Investment Research (zacks.com).

Zacks Investment Research