Permian Resources' Stability Makes It a Wise Hold for Now

So far this year, Permian Resources Corporation PR has clearly held up better than most of its peers in the U.S. Oil & Gas Exploration & Production space. While the overall sub-industry has dropped 21.4%, PR’s share price is down 5%, a smaller decline. That gap matters. In a tough year for the sector, PR’s ability to limit downside stands out and puts it ahead in the performance rankings. It is a sign that investors see something more stable or promising here compared with the rest of the group.

Year-to-Date Performance Snapshot

PR Stock’s Earnings Estimates

Over the past 60 days, the Zacks Consensus Estimate for PR’s earnings per share has been revised downward by 4.96% for 2025 and 7.69% for 2026, signaling some caution among analysts despite the stock’s relative resilience.

Factors Supporting Potential Upside

Peer-Leading Operational Efficiency and Low-Cost Structure: Midland, TX-based oil and gas exploration and production company continues to set new internal records for drilling speed and completion costs, demonstrating significant operational improvements. In second-quarter 2025, the company drilled five of its 10 fastest wells ever, including a record well completed in approximately six days. This relentless focus on efficiency drives down well costs, bolsters margins and enhances returns in any commodity price environment, providing a durable competitive advantage.

Proactive and Effective Capital Allocation Strategy ("Downturn Playbook"): Management has proven its ability to deploy capital counter-cyclically to drive outsized returns. During the second quarter, when market volatility was high, PR executed a $600 million accretive acquisition and repurchased $43 million of its own stock at a significant discount to the current price. This demonstrates a disciplined and shrewd approach to creating long-term shareholder value by buying valuable assets and equity when these are undervalued.

Significant Free Cash Flow Generation and Shareholder Returns: The company is a powerful free cash flow generator, reporting $312 million in adjusted free cash flow for the second quarter. This strong cash flow funds a sustainable base dividend, currently yielding 4.4% annually and a substantial $1 billion share repurchase authorization with $957 million remaining. This direct return of capital provides a compelling total return proposition for investors.

Successful Accretive Acquisition and Ground Game Strategy: PR has a strong track record of value-accretive M&A and leasing. The recent $600 million bolt-on acquisition from APA APA in New Mexico adds high-quality, low-breakeven inventory adjacent to existing operations — while peers like Coterra Energy CTRA and Cheniere Energy LNG have taken different strategic routes, such as focusing on core asset development and export infrastructure, respectively. Furthermore, the company's "ground game" added 1,300 net acres through 130 small-scale transactions, continually enhancing its asset base at high returns.

Strategic Marketing Agreements to Improve Realizations: The company has proactively entered into new firm transportation and marketing agreements for both natural gas and crude oil. These agreements are expected to significantly improve netbacks by more than 10 cents per Mcf for gas and over 50 cents per barrel for oil starting in 2026, adding an estimated $50 million to annual free cash flow by reducing exposure to discounted local pricing hubs.

Key Risks Impacting Outlook

Competition for Accretive Acquisition Opportunities: The company's strategy includes pursuing value-accretive bolt-on acquisitions. Competition from well-capitalized peers such as Coterra Energy, APA and Cheniere Energy for premium Permian Basin assets adds upward pressure on acquisition prices. This competition could drive up acquisition prices, making it more difficult for PR to find deals that meet the strict return thresholds and potentially slowing the consolidation strategy.

No Near-Term Plans for Significant Production Growth: Management has explicitly stated that, given macro uncertainty, the current strategy is to hold production "flattish to kind of low single-digit growth." For investors seeking aggressive production growth from an E&P company, PR’s current cautious stance may be viewed as a lack of a clear growth catalyst in the near term.

Dependence on Third-Party Midstream Infrastructure: The company relies on third-party operators for gathering, processing and transportation. Any disruptions, capacity constraints or unfavorable changes in terms of these midstream providers could interrupt production flow or increase costs, directly impacting PR’s ability to get its products to market efficiently and profitably.

Execution Risk in Integrating Acquisitions and Realizing Synergies: The company's growth strategy relies on successfully integrating acquired assets, such as the recent APA New Mexico bolt-on. Failure to integrate these assets smoothly or to realize the anticipated operational and financial collaboration could lead to underperformance, value destruction and a failure to achieve the projected returns on invested capital, damaging shareholder value.

Exposure to Inherent Volatility of Oil and Gas Prices: Despite hedging, PR’s financial performance remains heavily dependent on commodity prices, which are highly volatile and influenced by global factors beyond its control, such as OPEC+ decisions, geopolitical conflicts and macroeconomic demand shifts. A sustained period of low prices could pressure cash flow, hinder the ability to execute its downturn playbook, and negatively impact shareholder returns.

Verdict for PR Stock   

PR has shown impressive operational efficiency, with record drilling speeds and cost reductions, enabling strong margins and returns in any commodity price environment. The company's proactive capital allocation strategy, including accretive acquisitions and strategic stock buybacks, highlights its ability to create long-term shareholder value. Additionally, PR is generating significant free cash flow, which funds a sustainable dividend and a substantial share repurchase program, further enhancing total returns.

Compared with peers like APA, Coterra Energy and Cheniere Energy, PR stands out for its capital discipline and operational efficiencies. But with all these companies facing macro headwinds, timing remains critical for entry.

However, the company faces challenges such as intense competition for high-quality acquisition targets, limited near-term production growth and dependency on third-party infrastructure for transportation. Given this mix of strengths and potential challenges, investors should wait for a more opportune entry point instead of adding this Zacks Rank #3 (Hold) stock to their portfolios. You can see the complete list of today’s Zacks #1 Rank (Strong Buy) stocks here.

Want the latest recommendations from Zacks Investment Research? Today, you can download 7 Best Stocks for the Next 30 Days. Click to get this free report

This article originally published on Zacks Investment Research (zacks.com).

Zacks Investment Research