3 Energy Value Names Under $5 That Look Like Smart Buys

Oil started the year under pressure from changing government rules, shifting supply decisions by OPEC+, and global conflicts. This combination pushed prices below critical support levels, putting them on track for the biggest yearly drop since the pandemic. Most of this weakness comes from major oil exporters ramping up production faster than expected, combined with the United States hitting record output levels. This massive supply surge has reduced expectations that oil markets will be tight next year. However, this current period of lower prices is actually starting to create a safety net, or a price floor. Lower prices naturally encourage people to consume more oil, and the underlying, steady demand trends are still strong. Crucially, the OPEC+ group of producers is now acting very cautiously about adding any more supply. Together, these factors hint that the oil/energy market may be closer to stabilization than headlines suggest.

In times like these, quality value names, such as Drilling Tools International (DTI), Baytex Energy (BTE) and W&T Offshore (WTI),, tend to stand out. Their strong fundamentals and discounted stock prices make them appealing picks as the market works toward a bottom.

Looking Beyond Volatility for Hidden Value

With worries about a surplus dominating the narrative, investors may find opportunity where the broader market sees risk. The overall demand for oil hasn't actually crashed; in fact, U.S. consumption is holding steady near last year’s levels, and the business of turning crude into refined products (refining margins) remains healthy. As we move into colder seasons, the natural dynamics of winter could help support a gradual price recovery.

If OPEC+ continues to hold back on increasing supply and keeps a close watch on global conflicts, the pressure from high inventory levels should ease as winter progresses. In this kind of stabilized market, certain energy stocks that are currently undervalued — especially smaller companies trading for less than $5 — can offer a great way to jump into the sector just as it’s ready for a rebound, all while keeping the risk of major losses relatively low.

A Path Forward With Selective Upside

Despite the recent short-term troubles, the larger outlook remains encouraging. Steady, reliable demand, combined with the fact that producers are being careful not to flood the market, and the possibility of winter weather disrupting supply early next year, all point toward stronger market conditions soon. Analysts believe that if prices stay below their historical averages, big buyers — especially major importers in Asia — will step in, providing extra support.

Given this backdrop, investors should look for stable, high-quality small-cap energy companies. Stocks trading under $5, often called “penny stocks,” can present such opportunities, although they come with heightened risk and price swings. To help mitigate this, we have identified three stocks with solid fundamentals: Drilling Tools International, Baytex Energy and W&T Offshore. These companies also hold a Value Score of A, offering an additional incentive for investors amid the prevailing market uncertainty.

Our Choices

Drilling Tools International: It is a Houston-based oilfield services company specializing in downhole tools, machining, and inspection solutions for horizontal and directional drilling. With a fleet of more than 65,000 tools and technologies such as Drill-N-Ream and RotoSteer, Drilling Tools International supports well construction and optimization across major U.S. basins. Its footprint includes 16 domestic facilities and 11 international locations spanning the Middle East, Europe, and Asia, with over 90% of 2024 revenue generated in the Western Hemisphere.

Founded in 1984, DTI has expanded through acquisitions and steady investment in patented technologies, growing its portfolio from 2 to 16 patented products. The Zacks Rank #1 (Strong Buy) company participates in roughly 60% of North American drilling rigs and continues to scale its global reach. Drilling Tools International’s strengthened balance sheet, expanded credit capacity, and resilient free-cash-flow profile reinforce its ability to navigate fluctuating activity levels while supporting future innovation and fleet growth.

You can see the complete list of today’s Zacks #1 Rank (Strong Buy) stocks here.

At just over $2 per share, DTI presents an appealing option for energy sector investors looking for a stock with a reasonable valuation. Over the past 60 days, the Zacks Consensus Estimate for the company’s 2025 earnings has gone up 120%.

Baytex Energy: It is a Canadian oil-weighted exploration and production company with a diversified footprint across Canada and the United States. Its core assets include the Duvernay, Viking, Peace River, Peavine and Lloydminster plays, while the Eagle Ford in Texas has historically contributed about 60% of total output. This mix of light and heavy oil resources gives Baytex operational flexibility and exposure to multiple commodity markets, supporting a steady development pipeline across varied geologies.

The #1 Ranked company emphasizes disciplined capital management, using free cash flow to reduce debt, maintain a strong balance sheet and return capital through dividends and buybacks. Following the US$2.3 billion Eagle Ford sale, Baytex plans to accelerate shareholder returns and focus on high-return Canadian assets with significant long-term potential, particularly in the Duvernay and heavy-oil regions. With low leverage, conservative hedging and a commitment to efficiency, Baytex aims to deliver durable value and sustainable growth.

With a share price of just $3.22, Baytex Energy is a stock that energy sector investors should consider for investment. Over the past 60 days, the Zacks Consensus Estimate for the company’s 2025 earnings has gone up 64%.

W&T Offshore: The company is a Houston-based independent oil and natural gas producer with a long-standing presence in the Gulf of America. Public since 2005, W&T Offshore holds working interests in 50 offshore fields across federal and state waters and controls more than 600,000 gross acres. Its asset base features low-decline reservoirs, strong well productivity, and substantial remaining reserves, helping the company generate positive cash flow for over 28 consecutive quarters.

Founded in 1983, W&T Offshore has grown through targeted acquisitions and disciplined development. The Zacks Rank #2 (Buy) company has completed roughly $2.7 billion in Gulf of America acquisitions since its IPO and maintains a drilling success rate near 90%, supported by deep technical expertise. With reserves of 248 million barrels of oil-equivalent and daily production of 35.6 thousand barrels of oil-equivalent in the third quarter of 2025, WTI continues to focus on cost reductions, reserve life extension, and a steady pipeline of organic and acquired growth opportunities.

W&T Offshore shares trade for less than $2 as of this writing. An incredible bargain for investors, the Zacks Consensus Estimate for 2025 revenues of WTI indicates 32.6% growth.

Want the latest recommendations from Zacks Investment Research? Today, you can download 7 Best Stocks for the Next 30 Days. Click to get this free report

This article originally published on Zacks Investment Research (zacks.com).

Zacks Investment Research