BDL vs. RAVE: Which Restaurant Operator Is the Better Buy Now?

Restaurant operators continue to operate in a competitive environment marked by shifting consumer demand, cost pressures and the need to balance growth with operational discipline. In this landscape, Flanigan's Enterprises, Inc. BDL and Rave Restaurant Group, Inc. RAVE reflect two distinct approaches within the broader restaurant space. BDL operates a Florida-centric portfolio of casual dining restaurants and package liquor stores under the “Flanigan’s” and “Big Daddy’s” brands, while RAVE functions primarily as a franchisor of Pizza Inn and Pie Five concepts across domestic and international markets.

Flanigan’s combines company-owned units, limited partnership-operated restaurants and franchised locations, with revenue generated from restaurant food and bar sales, package store sales and franchise-related streams. Its model emphasizes operational control and brand consistency within a concentrated geographic footprint. Rave Restaurant, by contrast, generates revenue largely from franchise royalties, supplier and distributor incentive revenues and related fees. This asset-light structure reduces direct operating exposure but increases reliance on franchisee performance and system-wide sales trends.

With differing risk profiles and growth levers, the question is whether BDL’s regionally focused operating model or RAVE’s franchise-driven platform offers the more compelling outlook. Let’s take a closer look.

Stock Performance & Valuation: BDL vs. RAVE

BDL (up 5.3%) has outperformed RAVE (down 6.9%) over the past three months. In the past year, Flanigan’s has rallied 33.3% against Rave Restaurant’s loss of 8.1%.

Meanwhile, BDL is trading at a trailing 12-month enterprise value-to-sales (EV/S) ratio of 0.28X, above its median of 0.26X over the past five years. RAVE’s trailing EV/S multiple sits at 2.51X, above its last five-year median of 1.94X. While BDL appears cheap when compared with the Zacks Retail-Wholesale sector average of 1.81X, RAVE seems to be expensive.

Factors Driving Flanigan’s Stock

Flanigan’s operates in two distinct but complementary segments — full-service restaurants and retail package liquor stores. Recent results reflect growth in both restaurant food and bar sales as well as package store sales, highlighting the benefit of a diversified revenue base rather than reliance on a single channel. This dual-segment structure allows BDL to capture on-premise dining demand while also participating in retail liquor sales, providing multiple drivers of top-line momentum and supporting improved profitability.

Flanigan’s reported a meaningful improvement in operating income and net income in the most recent quarter, supported by higher revenues and disciplined cost management. While payroll, occupancy and merchandise costs remain key expense categories, the expansion in operating income suggests improving leverage within the model. This earnings momentum reinforces investor confidence in the sustainability of recent performance trends.

Flanigan’s maintains a healthy liquidity position with rising cash balances and manageable debt levels. The company continues to invest in real estate, including the recent purchase of property for future restaurant development, while also refinancing existing debt without increasing principal. This combination of balance sheet stability and measured expansion supports long-term value creation.

Factors Driving Rave Restaurant Stock

RAVE operates primarily as a franchisor of Pizza Inn and Pie Five, limiting direct exposure to restaurant-level labor, occupancy and commodity volatility. Its revenues are largely derived from franchise royalties, supplier and distributor incentive revenues, franchise license fees and advertising fund contributions, creating a diversified stream tied to system-wide retail sales rather than company-operated margins. This structure allows Rave Restaurant to scale with comparatively low capital intensity while maintaining operating leverage, as incremental system sales can translate into higher royalty and incentive income.

Pizza Inn remains the core growth driver, with domestic comparable store retail sales increasing in the most recent quarter and new buffet units opening during the period. Management has emphasized disciplined execution under its long-term strategy, focusing on profitable growth, value-driven promotions and improved development cadence. Continued unit stability and selective expansion reinforce the brand’s relevance and provide a pathway for sustained royalty growth.

Rave Restaurant maintains a debt-free balance sheet and high liquidity, positioning it to fund development initiatives and brand investments without financial strain. With limited capital expenditure needs under its franchise-heavy model, RAVE retains flexibility to allocate capital toward strategic priorities while preserving downside protection.

Choose BDL Over RAVE Now

While both Flanigan’s and Rave Restaurant operate within the restaurant space, their current valuation positioning and business profiles suggest different risk-reward dynamics. Although RAVE has made operational progress, particularly within its Pizza Inn brand, the stock trades at a valuation multiple that sits above both its historical norms and the broader Retail-Wholesale sector average. In contrast, BDL trades closer to its long-term historical range and at a discount to the sector, offering a more attractive entry point from a valuation perspective.

RAVE’s asset-light franchising model provides structural advantages, including recurring royalty streams, supplier incentive income and limited capital intensity. The company also maintains a debt-free balance sheet and healthy liquidity, which enhances financial flexibility. However, its overall system scale remains modest, growth is measured rather than aggressive, and the Pie Five brand continues to face performance challenges. With the stock already reflecting the recovery narrative and Pizza Inn momentum, upside may be more limited at current levels.

Flanigan’s, on the other hand, operates a more straightforward, locally entrenched restaurant-and-retail model with strong brand loyalty and predictable demand drivers. Its neighborhood-focused strategy and diversified revenue mix create steadier operating visibility. When combined with a more reasonable valuation relative to both its history and the broader sector, BDL presents a more compelling balance between stability and potential return.

Given valuation discipline, earnings visibility and relative operating steadiness, BDL appears to be the better buy now.

Want the latest recommendations from Zacks Investment Research? Today, you can download 7 Best Stocks for the Next 30 Days. Click to get this free report

This article originally published on Zacks Investment Research (zacks.com).

Zacks Investment Research