Bear of the Day: Goosehead Insurance (GSHD)

With a Zacks Rank #5 (Strong Sell), Goosehead Insurance GSHD stock is flagged as the Bear of the Day again this year after landing this mark in late January. Since then, GSHD is down 20% as I previously mentioned how the California Wildfires could affect Goosehead Insurance more than other insurance companies due to its weaker balance sheet.

However, even at $84 a share as opposed to a 52-week high of $130, Goosehead Insurance stock still appears to have more downside risk ahead and looks overvalued amid rising costs and increased competition.

Goosehead's Operating Expenses Jump 25%

Reporting its Q2 results last Wednesday, Goosehead Insurance’s operating expenses jumped 25% year over year to $78.4 million from $62.7 million in the prior period.

Notably, Goosehead is prioritizing long-term growth for short-term profitability, which can spook investors with Q2 EPS of $0.49 missing expectations of $0.53 despite sales of $94.03 million topping estimates of $93.91 million.

This comes as the company is planning to boost its tech investments in AI and expand its franchise, but was hit with impairment charges for existing underperforming leases.

Goosehead’s Stretched Valuaiton & Increased Competition

The real elephant in the room is that although Goosehead Insurance still has relatively promising growth prospects after going public in 2018, GSHD trades at a stretched 47.5X forward earnings multiple compared to its Zacks Insurance-Multi line Industry average of 9.8X.

Holding less than 1% of the market share as it relates to the U.S. personal lines market, Goosehead is vulnerable to larger industry players like American International Group AIG and Prudential Financial PRU, which trade at much more reasonable valuations. On the other end of the spectrum, Goosehead is being pulled into an AI arms race from emerging rivals like Lemonade Inc. LMND and Oscar Health OSCR that are also aiming to challenge traditional insurance brokers.

It's noteworthy that in terms of a more formidable valuation metric for up-and-coming companies, such as price to sales, Goosehead Insurance also trades at a stretched forward P/S ratio of 9X compared to the industry average of 1.5X.

Goosehead's Insolvency Problem

More concerning is that at the end of Q2, Goosehead Insurance's balance sheet revealed that the company now meets the criteria for potentially being insolvent. In this regard, Goosehead has $567 million in total liabilities, which is unpleasantly above its total assets of $437 million.

Bottom Line

One of the general rules of thumb when investing in stocks is to avoid insolvent companies, especially if it’s not a “cheap” penny stock under $5 a share or less. Unfortunately, Goosehead Insurance stock has checked this red flag and is experiencing a decline in EPS revisions for fiscal 2025 and FY26 following the Q2 earnings miss, which correlates with its Zacks Rank #5 (Strong Sell) rating.

Want the latest recommendations from Zacks Investment Research? Today, you can download 7 Best Stocks for the Next 30 Days. Click to get this free report

This article originally published on Zacks Investment Research (zacks.com).

Zacks Investment Research