Shell's Potential BP Buy: Strategic Scale or a Risky Gamble?

In the wake of blockbuster energy deals like ExxonMobil’s XOM acquisition of Pioneer Natural Resources and Chevron’s CVX pending merger with Hess, speculation around Europe’s largest oil company Shell’s SHEL interest in acquiring smaller rival BP BP has stirred fresh debate. If consummated, a Shell-BP tie-up would reshape the global oil and gas landscape, creating a European supermajor with the scale to rival ExxonMobil and outsize Chevron. 

However, despite media reports that Shell has been exploring such a deal with advisors, CEO Wael Sawan has reiterated that the bar for mergers and acquisitions remains “very high.” Speaking at Shell’s recent annual general meeting, where he won 98.7% shareholder support, Sawan emphasized that Shell’s current share price makes buybacks a more compelling use of capital. Chair Andrew Mackenzie echoed the sentiment.

Nevertheless, here's a closer look at both sides of the potential transaction. 

Scale Advantage and Competitive Positioning: If Shell acquires BP, the combined company would surpass Chevron in market capitalization and close the gap with ExxonMobil, forming the world’s second-largest publicly traded energy firm. Such scale could strengthen Shell’s leverage in procurement, logistics and technology partnerships. In a world where ExxonMobil and Chevron continue to grow via large-scale acquisitions (e.g., ExxonMobil’s Pioneer and Chevron’s anticipated Hess deals), Shell’s move could be seen as a strategic response to regain influence and secure long-term competitiveness in both upstream and LNG operations.

Synergy Potential and Cost Optimization: The merger presents real synergy potential. Shell and BP have overlapping assets in the Gulf of Mexico and the Ruwais LNG project. Rationalizing such positions could lead to operational efficiencies and cost reductions. Moreover, divesting redundant downstream assets could unlock capital for reinvestment in Shell’s LNG growth. Administrative and R&D overlaps, if streamlined effectively, may result in meaningful savings, improving return on capital over time and partially cushioning the debt required to fund the deal.

BP’s Financial Strain Could Burden Shell: Despite potential synergies, BP’s finances remain a concern. In the first quarter of 2025, Shell earned $4.8 billion, with a high-single-digit profit margin on $70 billion in revenues, while BP generated only $684 million in adjusted net income at a low-single-digit margin. Worse, BP’s $53.8 billion in long-term debt equals over 70% of its current market cap. Shell, by contrast, carries $65.1 billion in debt, just 30% more than its valuation. Taking on BP could dilute Shell’s superior performance, especially in LNG, which is a key profit engine.

Integration Risk and Weak Reserve Profiles: Both companies face upstream reserve challenges. Shell holds about 9.6 billion barrels of oil equivalent, while BP lags with just 3.7 billion. These limited reserves don’t compare favorably with ExxonMobil or Chevron. A merger might simply combine short-lived portfolios without addressing the structural deficit. Additionally, BP’s strategic shifts—from renewables back to hydrocarbons—may create friction when aligning with Shell’s longer-term plans, risking inefficient capital deployment and integration setbacks.

Conclusion:

While the Shell-BP merger could deliver scale, synergies, and short-term excitement, the strategic downsides are hard to ignore. Shell risks diluting its financial strength by absorbing a weaker peer. The potential for cost savings exists, but integration complexity and balance sheet strain may cap long-term returns. Shell’s management has signaled a preference for share buybacks, suggesting that the deal may not materialize. For now, Shell remains a Zacks Rank #3 (Hold) company on its own merits. BP stays a Zacks Rank #5 (Strong Sell).

You can see the complete list of today’s Zacks #1 Rank (Strong Buy) stocks here.

Want the latest recommendations from Zacks Investment Research? Today, you can download 7 Best Stocks for the Next 30 Days. Click to get this free report

This article originally published on Zacks Investment Research (zacks.com).

Zacks Investment Research